Sound Design Live

Build Your Career As A Sound Engineer

  • Podcast
  • Training
    • My Courses
  • Archive

What happens if you’re not familiar with a speaker?

By Nathan Lively

Subscribe on iTunes, SoundCloud, Google Play or Stitcher.

Support Sound Design Live on Patreon.

In this episode of Sound Design Live I’m joined by Manager of Technical Services at GerrAudio Distribution, Ian Robertson, independent consultant and designer of AV systems, Arthur Skudra, and previous vice-president now board member of the AES for the Latin American Region, César Lamschtein. We discuss career advice coming out of the pandemic and how Tracebook can support your work in the field when you run into speakers you’re not familiar with.

Tracebook is an independent public non-profit community that promotes the open exchange of loudspeaker system reference data measured by audio professionals for audio professionals.

Notes

  1. A Downloadable Speech Track… The Royer Track
  2. Tracebook Measurement Procedure
  3. Tracebook Forum
  4. Quotes
    1. Keep that hunger to learn.
    2. it’s nice to know what the room is contributing versus what the loudspeaker naturally is doing it’s by itself or what the other loudspeaker is doing and contributing in the context of that measurement. So having a baseline measurement of a loudspeaker is a highly valuable thing.
    3. it can help me select the correct speaker or select complimentary speakers to go on a particular job site.
    4. One thing that the trace will give you an no manufacturer gives you is the availability to, to mix and match different brands of speakers.
    5. The first discussion is…verification. A lot of people say, “Oh, ours is fine.” Nine times out of ten, I find something wrong. But what happens if I’m not familiar with the speaker? And I don’t know what I’m walking into, how do I know exactly? And Tracebook is a great resource for exactly that.
    6. I think this is really an a prime opportunity for any rental house to measure their entire inventory. And that way you have a baseline of what those speakers should be doing.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated. Please let me know if you discover any errors.

[00:00:24.490]
I’m Nathan Lively, and today I’m joined by the manager of technical services at Garre Audio Distribution, Ian Robertson, independent consultant and designer of AV Systems, Arthur Skudra and vice President of the AES for Latin American region, Caesar Lamschtein. Ian. Arthur Caesar, welcome to Sound Design Live. Okay, so I just gave it a tiny snippet of something that you guys are known for, but I’d love for you to talk a little bit more about your background, where you are in the world today so that people can relate to you and your experience. So maybe I’ll go to Ian first.

[00:01:01.240]
I’ll give you the short form history. 1970 is when I started all this. I started fiddling around with audio equipment. When I was in high school, a couple of friends of mine and I had a moderately successful DJ outfit that we ran around the high school dances and Church dances and things like that in the started a production company with a couple of friends in the went freelance and I was a Turing sound engineer. I worked at a production company. After I finished up, I had children, which brought me away from touring and I took a gig at a production company in the East Coast. I’m hail from Halifax, Nova Scotia originally, so I did that until the mid two thousand s. And then I made the move up here to Brock, Ontario to work with Gear Audio Distribution. So as a company, Gear Audio represents a variety of respected professional audio communications equipment, test and measurement equipment, pro audio equipment, console speakers, et cetera. And the primary function I hold here is I do technical support. I do a lot of system design and commissioning and education, basically for our product lines.

[00:02:16.320]
Awesome. And so I know that you’re teaching digital consoles smart. Anything else?

[00:02:22.090]
Myers Sound? I do training in Map 3D.

[00:02:26.750]
How excited are you about the Panther?

[00:02:30.290]
Quite.

[00:02:31.120]
Yeah.

[00:02:31.570]
Very. Yeah. I think it’s going to be a really fantastic Swiss Army knife type of enclosure that’s small enough and light enough, portable enough to do mid size gigs, yet have enough horsepower to do real full size shows, Stadium shows.

[00:02:49.390]
Cool.

[00:02:50.290]
I think it’s going to mean a lot of people can invest in a particular loudspeaker and use it across a wide variety of productions.

[00:02:59.030]
I immediately messaged Myers Sound and I was like, Is this in Map 3D already? And they’re like, no.

[00:03:05.210]
Okay.

[00:03:05.850]
So I don’t know when that plan to come out, but I’m excited to play with it in Map three D. Okay, let’s go to Caesar. So, Caesar, tell us a little bit more about yourself and where you are in the world today.

[00:03:17.030]
You may have the Panther in Facebook first before I have anything that’s possible.

[00:03:22.440]
If someone has it, they could measure it. That’d be great if they could upload it.

[00:03:25.530]
Okay. Now I am for one more week in my hometown, Montevideo in South America, Uruguay. I have to correct yourself. I am since a month, no longer the Vice President for the Latin American region of the Audio Engineering Society. I have been thrown away because I was not very good. So after four years of taking the duty, I passed the torch to Jorge Sama from Lima, Peru who is in charge today of the office. I am now in fact a member of the board of directors of Das. So I guess I am a director, which seems nice. It feels important.

[00:04:12.230]
Okay, alright, thanks. And then, Arthur, what about you? Where are you? And tell us a little bit about your professional experience that might help people get to know you.

[00:04:22.660]
Oh gosh. I’ve been an independent consultant for 20 years now. Been here in Canada based out of Hamilton, which is about an hour west of Toronto. Just to give a perspective of where I’m located in this planet. But I’m an independent audio visual consultant. My realm is more in the install industry, although I do occasionally live shows and concerts, things like that. But really my realm is more in the install business and commercial audio. But it’s kind of hard to pigeonhole what I do and where I am and what projects I’m working on. Because one day I could be working on an airport paging system and the other day I could be doing a performing arts hall and another day I might be working on a house of worship. My background actually started in the house of worship market and that started as a full time tech director for two big huge megachurches. So I was in charge of all the technical aspects of 4005 thousand seat auditory. So I’m well aware of all the challenges of lifestyle and making things sound right and appeasing some very demanding circumstances in terms of trying to make a sound system work and also these very picky ears and taking care of a lot of people complaining and trying to make everyone happy.

[00:06:00.420]
It’s not easy and anyone that thinks Church is a walk in the park sadly mistaken because you’re melding the two things together. You’re not only trying to make things musical, but also very intelligible. The music is just as important as the spoken word and designing a sound system that does both is particularly challenging and to tune and optimize the system to do both is also very challenging, but it’s always finding the right compromises. Lately I’ve been doing all kinds of interesting projects in the install side of business and with COVID I’ve been doing a lot more remote work. That’s the first. Normally I insist on being there in person to Commission a system and kind of forced my hand. And now I have actually a couple of portable kits that I fly around that essentially is a full measurement rig that’s in a Pelican case. And I can quite literally go in and remotely optimize and program the system. So I’ve been doing a lot of Nathan Lively, much to my chagrin. I still want to be there in person to actually hear the system. And I think the opportunities are really right now to get back into the AV industry if you’ve taken a break.

[00:07:33.970]
Thanks, Arthur. I didn’t know this about you with the House of Worship. I may have some personal questions for you later about some challenges I’m dealing with.

[00:07:40.940]
It’s a very unique market and it’s quite unlike what we’re used to in live sound. It’s very different and lots of unique demands.

[00:07:53.870]
Once you get a sound system set up for the first time, what’s one piece of music you want to play through it?

[00:07:59.550]
Yeah. There’s one in particular that I tend to rely on. It’s a tune by Chris Jones called Sanctuary, and it has a really nice low end and it’s really well produced track. But in particular, the thing that I like about this track is that his vocal mix and his vocal tonality is very broad range. And when you get the low mid OPA system nicely in line with the upper registers of the local range, there’s this lovely magic that happens with this track and what’s right. It just falls in and what’s right and it’s really good because if it’s wrong, you also know it’s wrong.

[00:08:42.680]
Okay, Caesar, what about you?

[00:08:44.610]
I would say that my tune that is always good in any system. When I need this, I pull out my Joker card, which is Street Worker by Michael Jackson that has great loudness potential. The arrangement is so well done that when there’s bass, there’s nothing else. When there’s no drum, there’s nothing else. When there’s the voice, there’s nothing there harming. So it’s like having a system per musical component so clarity is perfect. Bruce did a great job with that.

[00:09:18.130]
Great.

[00:09:18.700]
Good.

[00:09:19.140]
Arthur, what about you? What’s something you like to play on a system once it’s set up?

[00:09:23.040]
If I’m setting up a speech system, I have a couple of speech tracks, of course, the ubiquitous Synodcon speech test tracks that you can download for free.

[00:09:34.940]
Modern electroacoustics began in 1015.

[00:09:38.890]
Those are really helpful, but one in particular that I play back quite often is a Garrison Taylor track from Prairie Home Companion called Giant Decoys.

[00:09:51.610]
Okay.

[00:09:52.060]
There were some men in Lake Wabagan who were having a high old time notice last week. And I’m talking about the Sons of Canoe up at the Suns of Canoe Temple. They were busy all week down in the basement building duck decoys for duck hunting season, which starts in just a little bit, which is such a big deal for all those old guys.

[00:10:10.240]
I love the voice of Garrison. It’s like it has that deep rumble to it as well as the presence to it. And it’s just fantastic for setting up the sound systems. One thing, when you’re playing music through a system, your ears do tend to be a forgiving instrument in terms of any faults that are revealed in the loudspeaker deployment. If you throw a speech track through the system, your ears are a lot more attuned to whether something is right or wrong. And I find that to be absolutely invaluable to set up a system, especially if intelligibility is important. Run some speech through it and listen to it really carefully and critically. But other than that, for music gosh, I have a couple of Toto tracks. Of course, Steely Dan is the tried improving sound test tracks. Gaslighting Abbey, it’s fantastic, especially if you’re trying to pick up reflections or delays. You’re trying to time delay fills that snare drum and Gaslighting Abby is absolutely golden to be able to hear timing issues in the system.

[00:11:40.450]
Okay, we are going to talk about Facebook here pretty soon. If you don’t know what Facebook is, you’re going to be excited to hear about what it is. But I do want us to talk for a little bit about career advice. You guys have been in the industry for many years. Currently, there are a lot of people who are struggling to find enough work or getting back into work coming out of the pandemic. And anytime listening to this in the future, there’s going to be people listening to this who are working on finding more work or just finding a better fit, the work that they really love, that they are really good at. So I want to know from each of you one piece of career advice that you would like to share with people listening who might be struggling right now to find enough work because of the pandemic. So I’ll go to Ian again. First, only one last you guys for one track, and then you each gave me ten. So it’s hard to it’s hard to stop.

[00:12:32.880]
I think there’s a couple of things. Part of it is related to the pandemic, and the other part is what about the regular world when we’re not in pandemic times? So what I’ve seen or I guess the piece of advice would be flexible. Take this opportunity to learn some new skills, learn some different equipment, maybe not audio. There’s a lot of companies that we’ve seen that have made a shift to hosting, streaming production, particularly for large corporations. So we’re taking what would normally be our AGM and all the money that gets paid to fly people into major centers and put them in hotels and feed them. That money has become available to do these events virtually. And there’s a few companies that I know quite well that have done an excellent job at making that shift to hosting virtual events. They have basically television production facilities set up in their warehouses, and they’re running these events. So that’s one thing.

[00:13:39.340]
Yeah. If you already know how to work on shows, it’s not a huge deal to switch from doing an audio part of it to doing another part of it that might be in higher demand right now because of the lives.

[00:13:49.530]
Exactly. You might not get to mix your favorite band. You might be on a corporate gig, which may not be a spot, but you’re still paying the bills. So that’s one thing that few of my friends have had some good success with in the not pandemic times, if you will, or the regular times on gigs or all the time. Really, one of the chunks of information one of the suggestions I have would be is the importance of keeping it simple. Balance your keen interest of the latest fancy new thing with the complexity and the risk that might create as you implement it. I’ve seen a lot of folks get themselves in trouble. Basically, I do tech support, and I’m the guy on the other end of the phone that people are talking to, and it’s not working, and it’s an emergency. It’s because somebody has overreached, basically.

[00:14:46.090]
Can you give me a specific example? What’s something that someone has tried to what’s the latest new thing that someone tried to install that didn’t work out?

[00:14:54.430]
It’s hard to put a finger on something like that because you don’t want to speak ill of any particular technology. But I’ve seen people make a lot of mistakes in digital networking.

[00:15:07.570]
Okay, so maybe they switched from completely analog transmission to we’re going to switch over to Dante, and it’s a mess or something like that.

[00:15:14.940]
Basically, you’re either you’re sending signals out of a console over a piece of cat five to another piece of hardware and then back again, or you’re doing a bunch of different things. And there’s some benefits to doing that. But just keep in mind that whenever you do something like that, you’re adding another failure point. And the kind of goofy example, for lack of a better one, that I like to throw at people. Sometimes if you have to run 100 foot mic cable, do you go to the bin and take out 100 foot mic cable, or do you take out ten ft. Mic cables and plug them together? You’ve got nine more points of failure if you use ten foot Mike cables.

[00:15:54.860]
Small anecdote. I used to work for a company in the Bay Area where the guy didn’t own any 100 ft. Mike cables. He just always bought ten ft. Mice cables. Exactly what you’re saying. And we would just string them together. And it hurt me so much.

[00:16:07.210]
Whenever you’re in a heated, troubleshooting situation and you’re under the gun feet to the flames and you have to figure out what’s wrong, the fewer variables that you have in your mind, the faster you’ll be able to solve the problem. It’s a game of minimizing the variables and being able to come up with the answer quicker because you don’t have seven or eight different things to consider. There’s only three things to consider and you can get through those three things pretty quickly in your mind or in your methodology.

[00:16:41.190]
Awesome. I think that will connect well with what’s coming back to talk about Facebook. So Caesar, what’s one piece of career advice?

[00:16:48.750]
As pilot says you have to fly the airplane from the nose else the airplane is flying. You what I mean regarding this, I have always worked a lot in pre production because I love and because for me, everything is done before. When you go to the same for cooking, same for everything. Everything is done before doing it is just assembly of things already done. So when you have taken care of everything, usually there are no problems to be solved. Everything runs smooth. Music is the King. You don’t have any more technical issues. Shit happens. But just imagine what can happen if you didn’t do the pre level work. It would be a nightmare work before the gig. That’s my advice.

[00:17:48.460]
Thanks either. What about you, Arthur?

[00:17:51.270]
Gosh, there’s just so many things that I can think of, but I think if anything, just keep that hunger to learn. I think that’s really key to being relevant and staying relevant in our industry. Things are changing so fast and I think there’s a lot of us that have been dragged kicking and screaming into this whole new audio networking craze that has pretty much taken over the industry. And let’s face it, yeah, analog is great, but I think that ship has sailed and it’s still sailing. But networking of audio and video, all the AV systems now are all going through network switches. And whether you like it or not, that’s here to stay and it’s going to continue to advance more and more. I think if anything, the adaptability that you can present yourself in terms of learning how to harness this technology and be able to deploy audio networks properly is absolutely key. And I know in my work and in installs, we’re dealing with it every single day. And in fact, yesterday we wasted so many hours because one project that I’m working on, they never bothered setting up the network switches properly and all that.

[00:19:22.830]
And quite literally we were just baffled because there were IEMs on the network that were dropping offline. And yeah, we reset the switch, put in the QoS and everything like that. But it was so troublesome getting all the straggling pieces that still had the old network credentials try to get all that corralled into the new network set up was just an absolute horrendous mess. And the earlier you learn about how to do all this and do it right, the better off you’re going to be. And there’s so many seminars. Yeah, one thing about COVID is I got seminars out. I got absolutely fed up watching podcast after podcast after seminar after webinar. It just really got tiring after a while, and it was like webinar overload. But there are some really good seminars out there that are free for the taking. And you can learn so much about networking and being able to harness those things and getting those skills is just absolutely invaluable. Whether you’re doing live sound for a tour or doing a big, huge installation in a hospital or an airport or whatever, those skills are so transferable, and they make you that much more valuable as a person to be hired onto a job.

[00:20:56.750]
And I think if you want job security, face the fact that you’re going to have to get some data networking chops behind you. Otherwise you’re not going to be able to stand out from the rest. So that’s my piece of advice.

[00:21:14.610]
Thanks, Arthur. So I’ve been teasing that we’re going to talk about Facebook this whole time, and we’re finally going to get to it now. So what is Tracebook? Facebook is a website. It is a community, an online community for the exchange of loudspeaker reference data. So the first question that I have for the three of you is, why is this important to you? Like, why did you get involved? Why are you here today? Why do you care? And what’s important to you? Why is Facebook important to you?

[00:21:43.960]
One of the things that I try to impress on people whenever IEM doing a class is the importance of verifying that things actually work correctly before you start making decisions based on the measurement data that you’ve captured. So Facebook is a way to help you do that. I think that it’s valuable and important for people to have access to good quality actionable data. They can take a loudspeaker that they’ve never encountered before or one that they even have encountered before, but they’re not sure if it’s working correctly. And they can go grab the measurement off of Facebook and they can repeat that measurement procedure, and they should get pretty much exactly the same result. It may not be perfect because of the environment that they happen to be working in versus the way the measurement was originally taken, but it should be pretty damn close. And that gives you some confidence that the piece of equipment that you have in your hands or sitting on the floor or whatever is actually a good piece of equipment, it’s wired correctly, it doesn’t have damaged, low driver, high driver, or whatever. The preset is correct all the different variables that might pop up relating to a particular given loudspeaker.

[00:23:02.540]
You can cover them off and you can go, okay, I’m now confident that this is a good quality loudspeaker. And then when it comes to looking at a loudspeaker in situ, when you stick a microphone up in front of a loudspeaker that’s sitting in the corner of a room somewhere. Whenever you measure something like that, you’re not only measuring the loudspeaker, you’re measuring the interaction between that loudspeaker and all the boundaries in the environment that it’s in. Or you’re measuring that loudspeaker in combination with maybe some other sources, other loudspeakers it might be on as well. So if I need to address something, it’s nice to know what the room is contributing versus what the loudspeaker naturally is doing by itself or what the other loudspeaker is doing and contributing in the context of that measurement. So having a baseline measurement of a loudspeaker is a highly valuable thing.

[00:24:02.710]
Yeah, for me, that’s super relatable. We have all been in the situation, especially at the beginning. But even when we forget or in a hurry or we’re doing like a last minute gig, you walk into a room and you’re like, okay, let’s get things set up. Get my audio Analyzer set up, take a measurement. Oh, wait, IEM just looking at data in the abstract. I have nothing to compare it to. What am I looking at? Is this correct? Is this incorrect? Why does it sound this way? Is my audio Analyzer said there’s all these questions come up that could really be helped out by having some sort of a comparison. So I appreciate you bringing that up.

[00:24:39.570]
I guess the other part of that is if you’re in a shop and you’re either in charge of a bunch of loudspeakers in a shop somewhere or you actually own them, you can verify that your stuff is not broken. But also, if you’ve been handed a pallet, okay, you’re going to go and do this show and you’ve got these four different loudspeakers that are going to get pulled off the shelf and put in the truck, and you’re going to go to a show. Are they going to work together? Do they have complimentary faces characteristics? If I’m going to put an infill in an outfill with a big speaker on a stack, am I going to be able to make the marriage between those two speakers in the acoustic crossover area? Is that going to be nice or is it going to be nasty and it can help me select the correct speaker or select complementary speakers to go on a particular job site?

[00:25:32.330]
That’s really interesting. I ran a poll recently on Twitter and YouTube asking people, do you typically assume that two loudspeakers from the same manufacturer are compatible face compatible with each other, or do you typically assume that they’re not until proven otherwise? And I thought pretty much everyone would say that they assume that they’re compatible, but 75% of people said that they assume that they’re not compatible. And that really, I think people understand this problem that you’re describing, which is that should be the first question that comes into your mind is, oh, wait, you want me to set up two speakers together, or how do I know that they’re going to play nicely together and how do I prepare for that and how do I prove that being able to do that? Preproduction using Facebook sounds like a really valuable tool. Caesar, what about you? Why is Facebook important?

[00:26:26.240]
One thing that Facebook gives you and no manufacturer gives you is the availability to mix and match different brands of speakers. You talk about a single one, but that’s not the reality for a lot of us. You are sometimes giving something that it was not meant to work together and you can have data that would prolong what you normally use to predict performance. I don’t know either Map for my sound or Vision for this or Rainbow for that, or Easy, etcetera. There you have actual data that is vetted that you can use regarding different things where you can mix and match. I think that’s pretty valuable from one point of view of interest of Traceable. The other one is exactly the contrary. It’s a place in the learning side where you feel empowered to give to share. Am I measuring okay? Is this good enough? Etcetera. I think that you get a boost of confidence in how you measure when some guys, clever guys like those that are there scrutinize your measurements and you follow guidelines and you understand the guidelines and you go through this process for getting accurate data and at the same time it helps you to get also this other thing that is obscure arcane knowledge of what is accurate enough so you lose some fear.

[00:28:09.590]
It’s okay, we all agree, and I don’t know if he or Nathan or Merline or Arthur says it, so it’d be okay. You can do a measurement in this situation, you just take care of this, take care of that. No more than ten degree of repo, etcetera. Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So I think it helps you benchmarking your measurements, your own measurements, your own way to measure and to know how you get better at it. Basically, that’s it.

[00:28:41.510]
I think it’s pretty common that AV companies will reserve a sound system for the show they’re going to work on, but then for the little pieces for the front fills, side fills, delays, whatever. They might just use whatever is available at the time. They might be companies that are large enough or busy enough or just have a bunch of desperate systems that it’s just going to show up, whatever shows up and then it’s our job to make it all work together. And so the better that we can predict how that’s all going to go down, the better. Arthur, what about you? Why is Facebook important?

[00:29:12.260]
I think it’s great database to be able to do reality checks with. Oftentimes I get thrown into commissioning systems that I don’t know what the history is behind that system prior to me showing up on site and saying make something work here. Classic example. I had a house of worship and they had a cluster of two speakers, a center cluster, two identical speakers, and they were passively crossovered, and they were sharing the same signal on the power amp. So one amp channel powering, two speakers in a cluster, and we’re having a passive crossover. So to a loudspeaker from ex manufacturer, I come in, and the first thing I do whenever I come into an unfamiliar system is I’ll put a speech track through the system and a music track, and I’ll just walk the room, and I’ll just listen to the system and make some mental notes on what’s going on with that sound system. So I did that, and I started walking the coverage, and everything sounded fine on one side of the room. And then I went to the other side of the room that was covered by the other speaker, and things just didn’t sound right.

[00:30:34.770]
It was hollow. It was weird. And the transition between the two speakers was just really very odd. So out comes my smart rig, and I start measuring, and I’m going, okay, what’s going on here? And Unfortunately, I didn’t have the ability of turning one speaker off and just listening to one speaker by itself. Here I am speaker is 30ft up in the air. I don’t have any access to it. And I had to call the contractor and say, what happened to the system? We had a high frequency driver go out on it, and the alarm bells started going off. So I took some measurements of the system, and then I called up the manufacturer, and I knew personally the engineer there, and I shared them, my smart traces. And I said, is this real or is this not real? And if I had these traces in Facebook, Facebook obviously didn’t exist at that point in time. But if I had them available at that time, it would have saved me a phone call to the manufacturer, going through X number of different levels of support to get my question answered. When I’m on site, the clock is ticking, and I’ve got to be done X number of hours.

[00:31:59.830]
And here I am faced with get the system up running. And right today they have a service coming in that night, and I figure everything all figured out and fixed and everything like that. So I had to call them up. But if I had Facebook, I would have instantly recognized, okay, on this side, that trace looks plausible. On this side, the trace doesn’t look plausible. There is something really wrong. And it ended up that they replaced a driver, and the silly contractor wired the high frequency replacement driver out of polarity, which is not that hard to do, because when I know you go inside a passive two way box and they’re going to use all kinds of different colors for the wires, and you don’t know whether a yellow or green are plus or minus. And it’s an honest mistake that contractors make all the time. Even manufacturers make that mistake coming out of the box. And I’ve seen that happen. And it’s frustrating. That kind of thing is absolutely invaluable to be able to figure out what is going on. And I had to call the contractor, and they had to come out with a scaffold, set it up and go up there and fix the speaker the second time.

[00:33:20.930]
And once they did that, then everything started falling into place. But I think Facebook could prove its value over and over again. When you find those problems and measure up to what a good measurement should be and be able to establish whether something is correct or not, I would.

[00:33:43.820]
Love to hear some other specific examples from each of you. So, Ian, I’d love the story that you shared at Live Sound Summit.

[00:33:50.060]
Yeah, sure. That’s a good example, Nathan, because it’s not always a defective loudspeaker or it’s not always miswired cable. In this particular instance, it was a Meyer Lion rig. And we went in to do the tuning on the rig, and the first thing I saw was six phase wraps in the lion, and it’s a lot more than a lion has when you take it out of the box brand new. So then the investigation started. It’s like, where? Why? What’s going on? There’s something wrong with my measurement rig. What is it? So ultimately I asked the question, is everything flat in the console? Because I was running into the console? And so I said, give me an output from the console and I’m going to do a transfer function of the console itself just to verify. Again, I didn’t verify it on the front end. And sure enough, there was five phaser apps in the console, and it turned out to be a plugin that was inserted on the master bus of the console. And there’s a couple of ways to build those compressors. And one of them is to insert a bunch of crossover filters in the signal chain, which results in a bunch of phase rap.

[00:35:13.900]
Or you can have a bunch of crossover filters and you can side chain into the compressor from the crossover filters, which results in the signal path that doesn’t affect the phase wrap. So that’s what it was. It was saying it was a compressor. So there’s a whole bunch of different things that can pop up. Thanks for bringing that up, Nathan. That’s a fun example.

[00:35:34.430]
You know what a lion is supposed to look like, but for someone that doesn’t know, how would they know? They would just be like, okay, yeah, six page reps. I guess that’s how it is.

[00:35:44.550]
Yeah.

[00:35:44.760]
This speaker sucks. And I had another one very similar to Arthur’s, where it was a center cluster of UPAs. It’s a very long time ago, but it was the center cluster of three UPAs up top and then two UPAs aimed down into the Orchestra. And it was exactly the same as Arthur’s example, I walked across the balcony and the entire you lost all the low mid out of the cluster in the balcony. Okay. And then when I went to investigate, I found that somebody had inverted the polarity of the channel. They actually was physical. They stuck a phase invert on the input to the minor processor running to that speaker because they had discovered it was out of polarity. But in fact, it wasn’t out of polarity. The Horn was out of polarity and they had measured it and decided that the entire speaker was out of polarity. So they flipped the entire polarity of the speaker, thus putting the twelve inch out of polarity. So the horns all work nicely together. The twelve did not. So the answer, of course, was pull the cluster down, fix the speaker and put it all back, take the polarity invert out of the input to the M one, a process.

[00:36:54.430]
But yeah, things like this happen quite often. Gas to go in and do a tuning on the sound system. And one of the first discussions is we’re going to need some time to do verification. And everybody not everybody, but a lot of people say, oh, no, it’s fine, our system is fine. You can be confident. And nine times out of ten, I find something wrong. And Facebook, if I can find something wrong and IEM familiar with the speaker, that’s one thing. But what happens if I’m not familiar with the speaker and I don’t know what I’m walking into? How do I know exactly. And Facebook is a great resource for exactly that.

[00:37:30.640]
Caesar, what about you? Can you tell us about some way that Facebook has shown up in your work?

[00:37:36.980]
I have been asked as a consultant to see if they all have the same behavior, the same response. It was an RCF system that I didn’t know anything about. If I ask Myerson for data in order to buy a used Meyerson, what they are going to try to sell me a new one. They are not going to help me to buy a used one.

[00:38:02.950]
This is helping you do shopping because you’re thinking like, oh, if I buy a used system, I want some way to check to make sure that it’s performing.

[00:38:09.730]
You get confidence to get that.

[00:38:11.370]
Yeah, yeah, that’s great.

[00:38:13.060]
Exactly.

[00:38:13.600]
And I’ll just share personally, like this has happened. Day before yesterday, someone was asking me about two DMV speakers and they said, hey, how are you supposed to use these two DB speakers together? They don’t look like they match. And I was immediately suspicious because I’m not familiar with these speakers. I don’t know if maybe you did the measurement incorrectly, maybe you’re doing something wrong. It’s probably you. But I was able to go to Facebook, download those two speakers, look at them in my audio Analyzer, and move them around and adjust the delay and add filters and things. And I discovered that yes, he was right. These two speakers out of the box are not compatible, and you need to add an all pass filter for them to work together. Arthur, what about you? You already shared one story with us, but is there another thing that comes to mind for you for where Facebook has shown up for you and your work?

[00:39:02.200]
I’ve been using the database to compare different speakers. Now that we have the ability to do comparisons within Facebook, it’s been invaluable for me to evaluate different products to see whether from a design point of view, it will play together nicely. So that’s been one other area that I’ve been taking advantage of without having to Commission systems in the fields because we’re locked down. It’s been a very good design tool as well, not only for testing and verifying in the field, but also evaluating product that I’m considering to be part of a system. So very valuable in that regard, too.

[00:39:48.620]
We’re getting close to the end here, and I guess I want to see if there’s any last things that you guys want to say to people about potential ways they could be using Facebook or how to get started. And so one piece of news that I’ll share with people. Well, I’ll share two pieces of news. Number one, we have a little bit of new functionality on Facebook, which is that now you can make some adjustments to the measurements on the page so you can add and subtract delay invert polarity. And we have coherence blanking. And soon we’ll be able to look at two measurements on top of each other. So if you look at two things in the database, you can just grab one of them and put it on the same graph. And so we’re curious what other features people might want to make this a really valuable tool moving forward. We want this to be the de facto place that people go to when they have questions about what is this supposed to look like? Do these things work together? Any other exciting piece of news I want to share with people is that Caesar has spearheaded this work of translating the Facebook measurement procedure into Spanish.

[00:40:58.670]
And so there’s this whole other huge part of the world of sound engineers that we want to have access to Facebook to be able to use it, be able to do measurements and upload them to the website. And very soon we will have that document available in Spanish as well. So, Caesar, thank you for working on Turkish, not Spanish. Oh, Turkish. Sorry. Turkish.

[00:41:20.850]
You’re wrong. We are finishing it. The good news is that we already finished translation. We are reviewing it. We have input for the reviews from top of the top. You have Sauron Castanela, who already submitted his review. We will have people from Spain, from Peru, from Chile, Argentina, in order to be sure that it is neutral enough. So not anyone from a different place will find strange reading with some wording that could be locally. So it’s well done.

[00:41:58.510]
Awesome. Thank you for all of that hard work. I wouldn’t even have considered that we need to have Spanish speakers from different regions looking at it to make sure that is understandable globally.

[00:42:07.620]
I think I’d probably like to put a little bit more towards Caesar’s topic of community. I think Facebook is a wonderful community for like minded people to share and learn the skills of accurately measuring a loudspeaker and the procedures that we have put in place. And the document that has been drafted is a really great resource. It’s a really great guideline for how to measure a loudspeaker and get a good reference data trace out of it. It also clears up certain misconceptions and explains why the guidelines result in a quality measurement with actionable data. So it’s a learning document and it’s a growing document. It’s going to be something that evolves over time based on what we see as moderators with the submissions that are coming into the site. For example, I don’t know if other people agree, but the two things that I see that the mistakes I guess that people make is they either measure the loudspeaker too close to a boundary or they don’t get the tilt, so they don’t have the maximum high frequency on access in particular line of loudspeakers. And those are both outlined very clearly in the document.

[00:43:30.890]
So I think that Facebook has a great value on the educational side to help people in a very practical way to get really great data and learn more about measurement.

[00:43:41.300]
I’m really glad you brought that up. I forgot that this is a great opportunity for us to give tips to people who are interested in Facebook and want to use it not only to just like browse records and download things and load them into their audio Analyzer, which is the big first easy step, but for people who are going to take some measurements and go through that process, the people that we have here in the group today are the people that are going to look at that. For people who are totally new to Facebook, what happens is that you upload something, but then to actually have it be approved and accepted into the official database for trace book, it has to be approved by two moderators. So that means that someone like Ian and then someone like Caesar are going to look at it, compare it to any best known data that we have, and look at all of the details and decide if it meets the Facebook guidelines, which are all outlined in the measurement procedure. And that’s really helpful to know. Ian is saying that you got to get the vertical aim correct.

[00:44:43.870]
So that’s a big thing we’ve been working on in Facebook when you’re doing and we don’t tell people how you have to do the measurements. The ultimate result is that they have to meet the guidelines, and that’s it. But we are recommending that if people don’t have access to some sort of anechoic environment or other way to make a measurement that will meet the guidelines, we are recommending that they do ground plane measurements, and we go into a lot of detail on the measurement procedure about exactly how to do that. But Ian is just highlighting that one of the things that most commonly is done incorrectly and that we have to ask people to remeasure is when either the vertical aim is not correct and that means that you don’t have the speaker perfectly on access with the microphone, which we talk about how to do in the measurement guide, or what was the other one that you mentioned?

[00:45:37.630]
Too close to boundaries.

[00:45:38.570]
Too close to boundaries. So you see people measuring too close.

[00:45:41.080]
To the wall, too small a space.

[00:45:42.950]
So you either need to be in a large room typically, and then near the center of the room, but not exactly in center, but nine times out of ten, I just have to go outside, especially if it’s anything but a very small speaker. So I’ll throw it to Caesar and Arthur. Do either of you have some common mistakes?

[00:46:04.150]
The biggest mistake I see everyone making it is getting into audio. They should leave audio and go to something else. Where the money is and where happiness is. Video and lightning. But video mostly happiness isn’t video.

[00:46:26.690]
Yeah, I say jump in and make some measurements. I think if anything, too often people rush in and throw some gear together and make the measurements. Maybe they put some effort into it, but not enough effort. Let’s put it that way. I think if anything, we want to keep the data as pristine as possible to present to the world. We don’t want to put a speaker in bad light because of a bad measurement. And that’s why sometimes we’ll reject a measurement because we know that it doesn’t represent what that speaker can truly do. Don’t think of rejection as a personal thing against you, or don’t make it a point of frustration. Oh, I’m giving up on this because it’s too hard. It really isn’t. And I’ll be honest with you, any of us that are involved with Facebook would be more than happy to come out and help you make those measurements if we’re close enough.

[00:47:26.840]
Yeah, we can get on a Zoom call, whatever.

[00:47:29.060]
Absolutely. We’re all approachable, and we would love to help you make those measurements. I think this is really a prime opportunity for any rental house to measure their entire inventory. And that way you have a baseline of what those speakers should be doing whenever they go out on a gig and take advantage of this downtime that you have now, waiting for the show to come back to start prepping your inventory, measuring it all, making sure it all is working correctly, and take advantage of Facebook as your database to keep all those measurements stored somewhere and your gear ends up on a show. My goodness. This is a valuable resource for anyone using Facebook to be able to look at your equipment and be able to figure out, okay, how do I make these different systems work together nicely but jump in and really take some measurements and don’t take rejection personally. We all want to help each other and produce some great data here that everyone can use.

[00:48:40.370]
Yeah, I think you are. There. There. I hate to see people go to all the trouble of setting up their measurements and then there’s some really obvious problems. So what I’ve been recommending to people is to do something easy. Do something at home that you have easy access to So that you could just set it up in your driveway or a tiny speaker you could even just set up in your living room or your warehouse, take your first measurement, go through the entire procedure so you can see what it’s like. So that way we have problems with and we say, hey, you did this slightly wrong or can you do this a little bit better? It’s easy for you to set up again. If you have to get out of forklift and get down some giant speaker and clear out the room and go to a bunch of trouble and then we’re like, oh, but you had this thing upside down or whatever, then it’ll be disappointing. So do something easy first for your first time and then once you have hang of it or have the entire process then get out the forklift. All right.

[00:49:31.930]
Ian Caesar, Arthur, thank you so much for being with me here today. Final question where can people follow your work online?

[00:49:39.910]
I worked at gear audio distribution in Canada. We have our own internal Facebook and some stuff on YouTube and Instagram and whatnot Caesar, what about you?

[00:49:50.840]
I am on Facebook sometimes and the music I do in the studio using Spotify.

[00:49:56.840]
What about you, Arthur?

[00:49:57.910]
You can find me on Facebook or Instagram by all means find me there.

[00:50:02.740]
Or on LinkedIn trace book [email protected] and obviously I’ll put all the links links with the show notes for this interview but in Caesar and Arthur, thank you so much for joining me today on sound design live.

[00:50:17.450]
It’s great to be here.

[00:50:18.780]
Sound design. Bye.

Nothing in an audio analyzer tells you how good it sounds

By Nathan Lively

Subscribe on iTunes, SoundCloud, Google Play or Stitcher.

Support Sound Design Live on Patreon.

In this episode of Sound Design Live I’m joined by Advanced Systems Specialist at d&b audiotechnik, Nick Malgieri. We discuss the self-aware PA system and the future of live sound, cardioid subs, and why there’s no polarity switch in d&b amps.

I would like our d&b users to be thinking more about the artistic goal and making adjustments based on what they’re hearing and not getting lost in the science and the measurement and the verification. We’re trying to build a platform that doesn’t require that. And we can just focus on mixing or show.

Nick Malgieri

I ask:

  • What are some of the biggest mistakes you see people making who are new to sound system design?
  • The self-aware PA system and the future of live sound
    • If the most destructive part of the signal chain is between the loudspeaker and the listener, then what is the most powerful tool we have to deal with this destruction?What are some specific ways that d&b helps us with directivity?
    • Array processing reduces or eliminates the need to measure the PA on site.
    • Chris Medders : I’d be curious to hear how accurate he feels the phase prediction feature is when measurement values are precise in the field, and how effective that is for eliminating the need for TF measurements in varying sized rooms.
  • From FB
    • Chris Tsanjoures What is the best theme for a bar, and why is it Tiki?you seem to do a lot of traveling and consulting. If you think going a different direction than a clients current plan would be best for their situation, what are some of the things that you are able to identify a client needs, without them realizing they need it?
    • Christopher Patrick Pou What does a “typical,” mix bus section on any given mixing desk look like in an object mixing-based environment?
    • Gabriel Figueroa I’d also like to know why some deployments are not using the desk as the control of the objects and what the pros and cons are of this approach.
    • Peter Jørgensen whats the behavior in a endfire sub array with internal cardioid subs, like SL-sub.edit: What happens when you build an end-fire array with a cardioid subwoofer like the SL Sub?
    • Johannes Hofmann Whats the minimum distance of a cardioid sub to reflecting surfaces behind the sub to avoid cancellation in the lowend?
    • Istvan Kroki KrokaveczWhen will games be available on D40 amps?
    • Tomasz Mularczykhighest scores in D80 games
    • Benjamin Tan “How does engaging Array Processing change your tuning approach?”
    • Michel Harruch: Is there any plan to incorporate polarity inversion for the design of complex subwoofer arrays like gradient or end fire on ArrayCalc?
    • alexdanielewicz Why can’t you flip polarity in the d&b ecosystem?
    • Robert Kozyra How to identify the problem speaker(s) in a large array hang.
    • Daniel Brchrt How do I combine speakers from different series with unmatched phase response, like the T10 and Y7P?
    • Sunny Side Up Why have external amplification rather than built in amps?
    • Steve Knots what do you think about renting cranes to hang PAs rather than rigging them from truss?Well, I’ve seen photos of big festivals where it’s being done already so I’m curious about the whole thing — safety, rigging for crane lift, stabilizing / aiming the array, and of course security around the crane base to make an un-climbable fence wall type deal. I guess. Seems innovative
    • Wessley Stern What is their philosophy with sub/main crossover? It seem to me that they let there subs LPF be much higher than other companies, well above where the main cabs HPF is in most cases, resulting in a lot of LM summation. I really enjoy their systems and the perception this results in.
    • Vladimir Jovanovic Subwoofer driver sizes and uses. Is there a trend of releasing 21″ subs? Not just from d&b, but other brands too. Did the needs of events changed to drive this trend? (Pun intended, I know where the doors are) If there is a trend at all.

Notes

  1. Quotes
    1. Nothing in an audio analyzer tells you how good it sounds.
    2. I have never found a discrepancy in what the alignment says in ArrayCalc versus what I found on-site.
    3. Our whole design ethos is little, light, and loud.
    4. If you’ve done all the alignment in ArrayCalc, we don’t need Smaart.
    5. We’re trying to do as much of the science as possible for you ahead of time, so that when you get onsite, you can focus on your show and for the vast majority of applications, there’s absolutely no need for a polarity button because we already have cardioid subs.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated. Please let me know if you discover any errors.

I’m Nathan Lively. And today IEM joined by Advanced System specialist at DB Audio Technician. Welcome to Sound Design Live.

How’s it going, Nathan?

Going good. Just for you. I see that there are some special tools here that I have that would really welcome you. That’s the last time I’m going to do that.

Do we need a director to call sound effects on the show or what?

Stage manager. All right, Nick, I definitely want to talk to you about object based mixing and firearmies and combining speakers from different families. But before I do that, after you get a sound system set up, what’s one of your favorite pieces of music to play through? It to get familiar with it.

Actually, the first thing I usually play isn’t music at all. It’s a very simple recording, a very dry recording of a simple snare drum. For me, that’s a great way to check system timing. And when we play with soundscape systems, with emulated room acoustics, it’s a good way to hear the nuances of Reverb tales and stuff like that.

Cool. I would actually like to add that to my list of things. I’ll send you a link near Drum Sounds.

There’s a couple of things. I’ll send you a couple of things. Great.

Okay, so we had a lot of questions come in, so we’ve got a lot of technical topics that people want us to hit. But before we do that, we should talk about career and business stuff for a minute. I wondered if you could take a look at your career so far, Nick, and pull out some lessons that you’ve learned and that have helped you find more of the work that you really love. So what are some of the ideas that you can share with people that might help them look beyond maybe some of the typical front of house, mixed positions that people think of and just maybe some career advice that you have found over the years?

I think probably the first thing I like to tell people is never in my career did I get hired off of a resume submission.

You’re saying that my plan to just make a beautiful looking resume and send it out to everyone and then do no follow up is not a great correct.

Yeah. Not recommended. Every single job offer I got was like a verbal offer off of someone that I knew or met or we knew someone in common and I came as a reference or something. So I’d say as general career advice, just be around people, make friends with people, make connections, find an excuse to visit a company, find an excuse to visit a show site. Maybe you have a friend with an Inn or something, shake hands, make your smiling face known, and just be the person who is on the forefront of their mind when they’re in a last minute scramble and need somebody.

Yeah, that’s a great point. If the audio is based on personal referral, that’s such a great point about staying top of mind. How can you do that in sort of non manipulative and fun way, showing up, being places? Yeah, that’s great. It’s not a recipe, but it is something that is probably the opposite of just me sitting here at home waiting for the phone to ring.

Yeah, absolutely. And don’t forget, there’s a lot of markets in audio other than like, touring front of house engineers.

Tell me about it. What are some things I may have forgotten?

Let’s not forget about the in house gigs, right? In your hometown. There’s a lot of performing art centers, clubs, all that kind of stuff. And there’s a whole other world of audio called installation, which, by the way, was largely unaffected by Kofi. And a lot of people from the touring world just segue right over to installation, and only some of them are going back out on the road now that they’ve gotten used to spending the evenings at home with their families.

Now, is installation a place where I could continue working as a freelancer, or is it mostly employees? And so should I be going and looking at job boards or looking at their websites for openings? How do you recommend I get started with that?

The installation companies are probably more likely to accept, like, a cold call resume if they have an opening, but knowing someone there is still going to be the inside track. And in my perception, there are two kinds of audio installation companies. You have ones that maybe also have a touring division and really specialize in performance audio, and they have staff on hand that are audio ninjas to be able to really do high end systems. Then there’s a lot of installation companies that are really just responding to bid requests, and they’ve got the labor for the physical installation, the rigging and the wire termination and all of that stuff. But they might not do performance audio systems frequently enough to have an audio Ninja on staff. And a lot of those companies are either leaning on manufacturer people like me to come help Commission it, or a freelancer to come in and be their Ninja for that one off gig because the other five gigs are going to be like low voltage alarm systems and camera systems and stuff like that.

Maybe doing a little bit of research could help or at least knowing gain in. Oh, this is a place that focuses on performance, audio or this is not. And then coming into that conversation intelligently. Hey, I know that you guys don’t focus on this, and so I could really bring that to the table and be helpful in that way.

Yeah, that’s right. You can’t just ask for a job. You have to propose your value to somebody. So figure out what they’re missing and what you can provide for that.

Now, when you proposed to your wife, was it similar you’re here is the value. I bring this cow. I have a car.

No, something like that. Right.

Okay, let’s talk about technical stuff. What are some of the biggest mistakes you see people making who are new to sound system design?

I think the most common mistake always happens on show site, and it’s just poor prioritization on how to manage your day.

Like what?

Like spending too much time thinking about what’s happening on a Smart trace and not enough time thinking about just having a good physical layout of speakers. Or maybe this isn’t a great time to make noise because I’m pissing off other people who are working in the room. Hey, I’ve got a rigor in the air. I probably shouldn’t be blasting a speaker next to them or just spending too much time tuning a PA and not actually getting to a sound checkpoint, which ultimately is just as important as tuning the PA. Let’s just get it most of the way there. And if we find some time later, we go back and do some touch up.

What is the bad thing that’s going to happen if I don’t prioritize my time correctly?

Yeah. First of all, if you can’t prioritize your time and manage it, you’re going to end up missing meals or something. Then that makes a long day extra hard and unhealthy. So let’s take care of ourselves at some point during the day. Also, you need to be thinking about what’s the content for the show. How am I going to mix it? How am I going to route it all with this kind of stuff? What is the artistic priority as opposed to trying to make a PA perform quote perfectly on a screen?

Now I’m remembering back. I remember you have a pretty good story about prioritization and its relationship with smart. Do you know what story I’m referring to?

Yeah.

Can you tell us about that?

Yeah. I love this story. We’re good friends with the folks over rational acoustics that make the Smart software. And I had a really fun experience when they got a d&bA, and I was going to come out and help them tune it. And first of all, is a little bit of pressure because I use Smart sometimes for tuning. And the last thing I want to do is get caught using it wrong from the people that make the software. And I’m like you guys are going to provide the Smart rigorous. And it showed up. And we had two days allocated for commissioning and training and all of this kind of stuff. And because of scheduling and travel conflicts, day one, I was working with Jamie Anderson from Rational, and on day two was Chris Andrews from Rational. And so two days we got to tune a PA with two separate people that work for the company that makes the tuning software. And I showed up to a very well installed PA. First thing I did is make noise, come out of all the right places, and verify that it’s wired correctly and stuff. And then we had the standoff moment with each other where it was like, So how do you want to do this?

And they looked at me, how do you normally approach this PA? So we started to get into it. We walk in the room making some changes by ear, showing them how rate processing works and this kind of stuff. And after the end of day one, they were like, this is great. Let’s go to dinner. And I realized never once had we looked at Smart. Well, it was sitting there running the mic was there. We just never placed the mic. We never did anything. We never heard something that we needed visual feedback to correct. And so then Jamie leaves. In day two, Chris shows up, and Chris is like, I don’t care what you did with Jamie yesterday. Let’s reset it and do it again. And so we tune the whole PA differently, but in a similar style, using our ear, walking the room, and never once looked at Smart. And it was a really good reaffirming moment to me that even the people that design it, they like to say there’s no such thing as Smarting up here. It’s a tool. Use your judgment, be influenced by the artistic goals of the show and the logistic constraints of your venue.

And Smart is there if you need it.

Yeah, that makes me think that the audio Analyzer. Maybe I should be thinking about it more as a verification tool, as a problem solving tool, unless as a qualitative tool that says, IEM going to tell you what’s good. Nathan, I’m like, okay, all right. Audio Analyzer. You tell me what’s up and I’ll do it.

Yeah. I’ve heard really well measuring Pas that I don’t like the way they sound. And I’ve heard very poorly measuring Pas where the second I push up some channels on my mixer, like, this is great. I love this. So, yeah, nothing in an Analyzer tells you how good it sounds.

Okay. During the last Lifetime Summit, you gave a great presentation called the selfaware PA System and the Future of Live Sound. And if people want to listen to that, they can go to Livesonsum at 2021 Soundslive.com. But a couple of follow up questions about that presentation. If you say that the most destructive part of the signal chain is between the loudspeaker and the listener, then what is the most powerful tool we have to deal with this destruction?

Yeah. And just to clarify that these days, year 2022, we have these pristine signal chains of all digital, high bit rate, low noise floor, virtually zero cross talk. And then the sound leaves the speaker, and we’re still subject to the same pesky physics that we’ve always been subject to, and we can only control so much of that. And that is what is turning into feedback. That’s what turning into intelligibility, lack of impact, all of that stuff. The best tool for us to avoid this primary source of degradation is directivity. The more that our loudspeaker can focus on where we want it and avoid all other directions, reflective surfaces and open microphones, the better the PA is going to sound before we’ve touched an adjustment at all.

Wow.

Okay.

And so what are some of the specific ways that d&b helps us with directivity?

On the subwoofer side, it’s all about cardioid subs, not just to cancel sound on the rear at some frequencies, but equally across all frequencies, so that even if you are on the back side of the sub, you’re still getting a proper representation of the frequency response, just quieter. Then we have the SL series line array cabinets, which have side firing low frequency drivers that not only add more energy to the front, but cancel on the back, which is great as you walk off axis one of those rays, all frequencies get attenuated evenly. And then even on point source cabinets, we rely a lot on what we refer to as a dipole, which is two smaller low frequency drivers instead of one larger low frequency driver. And those two smaller low frequency drivers are spaced out in the cabinet so that they create summation directly on access, but cancellation in other directions. Not only do we get good directivity out of the frequencies coming out of the Horn, but we get added directivity of lower frequencies as cool.

Okay, so another thing that you said during that presentation is that array processing reduces or eliminates the need to measure the PA on site. And that connects with one of the questions that came in from Chris Meters, who says, I’d be curious to hear how accurate he feels the phase prediction feature is when measurement values are precise in the field, and how effective it is for eliminating the need for TF measurements in varying size rooms. Funny way to say that. And the subject he didn’t mention there is I think he’s referring to a Ray Calc. Would you agree?

Yes. So it sounds like there’s two questions there. One is about a rate processing, and let’s put a pin in that for a moment. The other one is about the ability to tune your PA quickly and accurately within the software before you’re on site. And to answer the question simply, I have never found a discrepancy in what the alignment says in a Ray calc versus what I found on site. Even when I put up a mic to verify it’s within ten degrees of phase wrap between the subs and the tops and anything there couldn’t be much more perfect. And why would I want it to be more perfect at a specific location anyways? The idea of alignment is to make it work for a larger portion of the audience as possible. And one of the main benefits of using the software to do this is you can very quickly with a couple of mouse clicks, pick multiple points for your measurement microphone, and verify if the timing decision you’ve made translates not only to the 100 level, but also to the 200 level and the 300 level. Whereas if you’re on site with a microphone that just turned into a 45 minutes process just to get the mic from the 100 level to the 200 level to the 300 level, and who’s got time to do that?

When tuning, you load in at eight and sound checks at noon or something. So it allows you to be more informed from the comfort of your home. And as long as your file is accurate to the way the PA is deployed on site, you just push those settings to the amps and then bust out smart if you find yourself with some extra time and energy that day. Now, rate processing is very similar for anybody who doesn’t know. Rate processing is our technology, where each cabinet within the array requires its own DSP, path and amp channel. But this allows every cabinet within the line array to have a different signal sent to it, so that the behavior of the array as a whole matches the geometry of our venue better than we could with just mechanical splay. So this means we need to have an accurately represented array, proper height, proper spray angles, all that kind of stuff. And within the array calculation, we need to make sure we have accurate venue geometry. Then the software can say, okay, now I know the relationship between the PA and your audience areas. Let me optimize myself for perfect spectral response from the front row to the back row.

This does a couple of things. One, it corrects for weird HF peaks and dips and all this stuff. It fixes Farfield HF reduction because of air absorption, and it makes the PA hit a target curve at the listener positions, so it will hit the same target curve in the front row as it does at front of house and at the back row. And if you have a rate processing enabled on other parts of your PA, like delays and sides and 270, all of those parts of the PA are now hitting the same target curve at their respective audience positions. So this way now you don’t have to worry about level matching and spectral matching different parts of your PA, which is the biggest part of measuring the PA. Now you can just say, oh, the whole thing is too much lowmade. I’m going to pull out some 250 Hz and apply it to all parts of the PA. And they’re all going to respond much more similarly than they would without a rate processing.

That’s so cool. And I’ll just add that it is really fun and so powerful to be able to check all those different alignment positions really quickly. If you’re like me and you want to try to calculate the best alignment position ahead of time, and then you do that, and however you do that, then you just have to accept, okay, this is going to work. It’s really nice in a Ray calculator. You can then verify, oh, yeah, this is the right one. Okay, great. And so I like that tool a lot.

Yeah. There’s only one gig I’ve ever had where I really cared about making the whole system align in one specific mic position. And in a previous lifetime, I worked for a rental company out in California that Myers Sound used to hire for their internal events, like their parties and stuff like that. And then my question was always like, Where does John Myers sit? He’s the one whose name is on the check. He’s the one that can hear the difference. Let me make it a line there, and everybody else can just deal with it.

Tell us about the biggest or maybe most painful mistake you’ve made on the job and what happened afterwards.

What’s the old joke? In our business, I’ve screwed up bigger gigs in this one. Expertise. What is it saying? Wisdom comes from expertise, and expertise comes from failure. We can do these one liners all day long, but it’s true. Making the mistake is the way to learn and be a better person. And we’ve all done them. I was working a show. We’re Loading it in. I was working in the doghouse of an analog console, if anybody remembers what those are. And I was pretty pissy. It was a rough day. It was a gig at a winery where we loaded it on grass, and I was trying to figure out how to make this console sit level on a grass embankment next to the stage. It was hot. There’s mosquitoes. I’m just pissy. And the voice behind me, someone on the stage, it’s empty. They’re like, no audience. There’s no artist yet or anything, but his voice is like, how are you? And I was like, this is fucked up. And I just totally went off and just, like, verbal diarrhea on how I was feeling and turned around. And it was the main headliner artist singer of the show, and was like, oh, God, what have I done?

And he ended up being really cool. I hear your brother. This is a hard work environment. Just keep going. I really appreciate it. That was when I turned around who would say something so nice.

He could have been like, who is this guy? Get him out of here.

Totally. And that’s all it takes. Just rub someone the wrong way and he’s thinking about his pressures of performing, and he doesn’t want my negativity involved. And I’m the monitor engineer. So if I’m going to be like that during rehearsal, it’s gain to ruin his vibe. So he could have just said, yeah, get them out of here. And then that’s it. I’m fired. And once that happens, you never get that gig back.

I don’t know if this is great career advice, but a friend and student of mine got a new job once, and it was a really important one for a big, well known company. And I said, hey, I think one of the best things you can do from my experience is to figure out as quickly as possible what things are going to push your buttons and then figure out how to deal with that. Because the worst thing is that it becomes a surprise that’s when it’s really painful is. Yes. All these circumstances. Yes. All this pressure and stress, and then also a surprise, like something falls on your foot or something is late or whatever, things go wrong. And so if you can sort of get ahead of that somehow, man, it can really help because that’s the difference between saying something you really regret to a manager or something, and then you have a whole thing to deal with.

Totally. I feel like one of the best professional advances I’ve made came as a byproduct of moving to the Southern US, where I just had to learn how to keep my mouth shut more than I’m used to. I think people in the south tend to be a little bit more cordial, a little more polite, and they complain in a different way. And that’s been a good career and life skill for me.

Christian Giroud says, what is the best theme for a bar and why is it Tiki?

Oh, yeah.

What are you talking about?

Yeah, one of the things I missed most during the COVID era is hanging out in some town where there’s some trade show like Info.com or name or something, and ending up at Tiki bars with rational acoustics guys. Okay, they love a Tiki bar. I love a Tiki bar. And we need to get back to this trade shows just for the Tiki bar. I couldn’t care less about the trade show. As soon as 05:00 hits and we’re all looking at each other, am I going to get a blue drink or a green drink? That’s what that week is all about.

So Chris says that you seem to do a lot of traveling and consulting, and this question that I’m going to paraphrase, which is basically, how do you handle these situations? Or have you been in a situation where it seems like the client wants something and they’re saying, this is the result that I want, and so here’s how I want to do it. But you know, that’s not going to get them the result.

Yeah, that’s the hardest thing about audio, right? Human beings are visual thinkers and audio is invisible. So everybody has an idea of how to do it, and there’s no real way to prove it. And even your average person might not know how to listen to the PA to know if it was achieved or not. So it’s all about being a bartender and playing psychology and just having good verbal interactions. And there’s a way to advocate for what you think is the right decision without knocking down a client’s request. I think there’s a way to verbalize that there’s a certain approach. Just don’t be the annoying it guy who’s just no, that’s not how it works. You don’t know what you’re talking about. No one wants that kind of audio person. Just speak normally with them and say, So what I’m hearing is repeat what they’re saying. It makes them feel heard and say, how about this? What if we tried an approach to do this and explain in simple terms why you want that approach? And I find it’s really hard for a client to argue with that. It almost makes it feel like it was their idea to approach it the way you want to approach it.

And you’ve told me in the past that a rake out can be a tool to facilitate these discussions. Sometimes it really helps to have a visual element. This is what you want. Here’s how we can do it. What about this? What about that?

Small churches and clubs and venues that want a line array, but it’s too small of a room for a line array? Let’s look at it in a Ray calc. Let’s show you how a line array performs versus a point source, and it will be immediately apparent that there’s a really good discussion there. And if in the end you want to win array whatever it’s your PA, you can buy whatever you want. But at least I advocate for what I think is best.

There’s a bad movie podcast called How Did This Get Made? And I don’t listen to it that often, but it comes to mind in this moment because we’ve all been in music venues all over the world, but even here in Minneapolis, I’ve been into several music venues where the PA does not fit the room. And you’re like, how did this get made? These two big arrays, half of it’s just playing into a balcony and a wall, and it doesn’t seem to fit it’s.

Funny, this is the number one theme of being a support person for d&b Audio Technic, because our whole goal, our whole design ethos is little light and loud. How do we get very high directivity, high bandwidth and high output out of the smallest cabinet possible? And our clever Germans do a pretty good job. Meanwhile, we have people coming and saying, I don’t want that speaker because I don’t think a pair of tens are big enough. Woofers, which used to be the simplest method of evaluating loudspeaker. You have to explain to people, no, you don’t understand. This pair of tens has more low frequency extension than our old speaker that had a 15.

So you’re finding some preconceptions about just things people think about the size of related to power quality. Okay. Christopher Post says what does a typical mix of section on any given mixing does look like when in an object based mixing environment.

So let’s be clear. When you’re using soundscape and object based mixing, there is no master bus in your console. We need different performers, different types of signals to hit that process. Or the processor works is like a summing matrix with the spatialization data and renders that to the PA using delay and level distribution. So then this is a great question. How do you feed the processor from the console? The short answer is there’s no one way, there’s no one way to sound scape. But I could give you a very kind of simple anecdote that represents a lot of projects that I work on. Let’s say it’s a typical band. So maybe Kick, Snare, hat come out of a mono bus and send it to a processor where we can place Kick, Snare, and hat within our mix using a sound object. Then maybe a stereo mix that has all of the Toms and other drums. Those come in as two sound objects, and we can make those Toms big and wide or accurate and sound like they’re coming from the drum set. And then maybe another stereo bus for overheads and chimes and percussion stuff that maybe wants to go wider than the Toms.

Then maybe you have a bass player who has an electric and an acoustic and a Di and a mic, and I don’t know, a foot pedal organ thing or something. All those inputs can come down to a mono bus called Bob the bass player, and then Bob the bass player’s bus comes into a sound object that we control in our one called Bob the bass player, and we can place that where Bob is located might do the same thing for guitars, keyboards, bust them down, but then send them to the processor in a way that represents an individual performer. And then as you get to your money channels, your lead vocals, your pastor Mike, your CEO for the corporate event, those might be post Fader direct out of the console. All your channel strip processing works. Your Fader affects the level of that, but it immediately leaves the console and gets summed in the processor where each singer can have their own sound object. That way, when people sing together, they’re not stepping on each other in the mix. You want to listen to the Alto or the tenor you can DeMask it binaurally just like we do in an acoustic world and retain clarity headroom and require less processing on the channel strip to get it.

Related to this, Gabriel says, I’d also like to know why some deployments are not using the desk as the control of the objects and what the pros and cons are of this approach.

Yeah. So if you have a soundscape system and you’re using an Avid S Six series console or digital SD series console, you can control soundscape natively from within the console. And I know it sounds awesome and it can be your object parameters are being saved within your scenes of a console, and that’s really nice. But for a large venue and we have 100ft of travel where the sound object could be through the mains and maybe sides if you have them. And that 100ft is now represented by a three inch by three inch quad panner on your screen, it’s not as meaningful as you would think.

The scale is off, right?

And we can scale the stuff separately from what the console sends into what the processor receives. But yeah, three inches to represent 100ft is pretty coarse no matter what. So I always tell people, let’s think of it as like a wave control computer. Let’s just have our one running on a touchscreen, hovering right over your console like your wave screen does, and you can just touch the object to move it. You get a full size screen, you can visualize the room better, you can put in a seating chart. So you really know when you’re placing a sound object exactly where it is instead of just placing it in this vague square on the console.

Peter Jorgensen says, what happens when you build an infrastructure with a cardioid subwoofer like the SL sub?

Yeah, I’ve done it with the SL sub and other subs and from other manufacturers subs, because I’m not just a DB guy, I’m also just a sound guy. It works well. It’s cool. You don’t have to make an end fire out of omnidirectional subs and you can mock this up in a Ray calc. There’s this myth out there that you can’t do in fire Subaru in a Ray calc. You most surely can. It will automatically calculate your delay times for you as well. And if you want to learn more, send an email to [email protected] and we’ll show you how to do it. But to answer the question, we have some cabinets that are cardioid by themselves and then we put them into an end fire. And of course it depends on your spacing and the number of cabinets within the array and the delay times, etcetera. Etcetera. But essentially it turns it into hypercardiot. And I did it. I do a gig every year at the Monterey Jazz Festival and I run the main stage there and I do an end fire of cardioid subs. And the reason is twofold one, it’s a wooden stage that resonates.

I think it’s right at 78 Hz. Oh, wow. Yeah. And it rolls pretty slow. It used to be years ago, the stage would hear the feedback long before front of house did, and they would just hit the call button on calm. And if I was at front of house and saw that call button lighting up, I would just immediately pull the subs back because I knew it was coming. And so when we put ourselves in an NFL array, it allows me to change the delay times so that I can take that 78 Hz null and point it directly at center state, so that it’s really trying to cancel that one frequency in that one direction to stop the stage from resonating. And that feedback. And the second reason I do it on that gig is because I don’t have anywhere else to put the subwoofers. So it’s a win win in that I can’t stack them high because it blocks sight lines. I can’t do them horizontally across the front because their VIP section would be like their knees would be touching the subs and they wouldn’t be very happy about that. So they have to be up on the deck, but only one high.

And so then putting one in front of the other is the only way to make them fit.

All right. Johannes Hoffman says, what’s the minimum distance of a cardioid sub to reflecting services behind the sub to avoid cancellation in the low end?

Yeah, this is a really common question, and I totally get where it comes from, because when you have a speaker firing in the back of the subwoofer, it seems like it needs some breathing space. And it does, but not as much as you’d think you can. Actually all the d&b cardioid subs, they have the casters on the backside, so you flip it up to roll it. So then when it’s lying down, the casters point backwards and I just tell people push it all the way up to to the casters touch the wall. It only needs that four to six inches that the caster represents.

Okay.

However, most people don’t realize when you have a cardioid sub, you really need to maintain 2ft of open space to either side. It actually needs more space on the sides than it does in the back. And that’s because we need the sound to wrap around the sides to interact properly between the rear driver and front drivers. So, for example, we see people all the time that might have, like, an SL sub, but they’ve decided to place it up on end so it’s higher. Maybe that’s because they want to put a front fill on top of it or something, and it works and you can do it, but it eliminates one path length around one side of that cabinet because the side is now obscured by the ground. And undoes a whole bunch of the cardioid effect and it ends up turning into kind of like a loose cardioid.

We don’t want loose, we want tight.

That’s right. In a breakout, you can select between an SL sub and an SL sub upright, and you can look at how that affects the rear rejection.

Okay, Eston says when will games be available on D 40 amp? So this is news to me. Apparently there are games on some amps, but not on other amps. Tell me about that.

Yeah, all d&b amplifiers have games built in, and you should know that if you perform a firmware update on a d&b amplifier, it will reset all the settings, as you would expect with a firmware update except for its IP settings. So it doesn’t reset the network card, which is very convenient. And it also does not reset your high scores in the games. Critical and even the really old amps had simple games. Then we came out with the fancy four channel amps with the color touchscreen and the games got way better. And now we have this brand new amp platform that I suspect will eventually get the games. But to be honest, our software team has been working really hard making all of the audio features work correctly in the brand new amps, and I would rather they prioritize that than the games at the moment.

So Thomas wants to know the highest scores in the D 80 games, and I’m guessing these amps don’t report back to you and you don’t have a list, but I think we were talking about how it would be fun to have a leaderboard so we could see self reported who has the highest scores.

Yeah, or log it within our one, since you’re already on the network with your computer so you can have your own list, you don’t have to go back to the amp to find your high score reported back to Dbau.com, so we can keep track of who’s winning the games. We also get a feature request quite often that people want to be able to play multiplayer games across the network on front panels amp so the stage right fly guy can play against the stage left fly guy during the show.

Benjamin Tan says how does engaging array processing change your tuning approach?

It’s all part of the PA performing nicely and more like each other. So even if we have a main hang of 24 GSL and a side hang of twelve V, those are voiced to the similar target curve. So I don’t really have to worry about matching curves, even though they’re different box counts, display angles and box type and all that. And it’s doing things like mostly or completely fixing the kind of HF peaks you get right down in the front row underneath the line Ray, that kind of Fresnel effect. It gets rid of that. Which, by the way, really resolves feedback issues. If you have an artist that ever goes out on a thrust in front of the PA. It fixes the HF absorption issue in the back rows, so I don’t really have to worry about tuning for that. At the end of the day, I just need to voice the PA overall for whatever my overall mix is going for. We already have controls, like a coupling filter is what we call it in our one where we can change kind of the overall voicing of lows to highs. Do you want a flat response or do you want the case stacked low end for a lot of power?

And we can just make those broad adjustments and then maybe put in an EQ filter or two, depending on what I’m feeling, what I’m hearing, and you’re done. And if you’ve done all the alignment and Raycock, we don’t need smart soundscape systems are similar. This is why I talked about the self aware PA on the soundscape. The processor knows where every loudspeaker is located and how it’s pointed, and so it times itself. You never enter a delay time into a soundscape system. It realigns itself based on where you want the sound to come from. So I would like our d&b users to be thinking more about the artistic goal and making adjustments based on what they’re hearing and not getting lost in the science and the measurement and the verification. We’re trying to build a platform that doesn’t require that, and we can just focus on mixing our show.

Yeah, that’s cool. It sounds like there’s this idea of letting the computer do what computers are good at, and let’s have the humans do the creative decisions that the humans are good at.

I love it.

Michelle or Michael says, is there any plan to incorporate polarity inversion for the design of complex subwoofer arrays like Gradient or In Fire into a Ray calc? And they are expressing this sort of surprise that I remember having as well the first few times working with d&b systems and realizing, oh wait, there’s no way to insert a polarity inversion. But referencing back to the clever Germans, there must be a reason for excluding this.

Yeah, we don’t have a polarity button. The amplifiers and the filters available to you within our one do play with polarity as needed to get the behavior we want out of the cabinet. And this is a contentious issue. We’re used to having a Polarity button. And why would a high end manufacturer like d&b just take that feature away? And in general, this kind of comes back to this ethos that I just described, where we’re trying to do all of as much of the science as possible for you ahead of time so that when you get on site, you can focus on your show. And for the vast majority of applications, there’s absolutely no need for a polarity button because we already have cardioid subs, we already have full broadband connectivity. We already have all these benefits built into the PA, as is and we all know a lot of sound engineers that can dig themselves a whole pretty quick by hitting polarity buttons and not entirely knowing what they’re doing. With that being said, I do recognize there are kind of niche setups where this would be handy. And if you want this as a feature, please don’t be shy.

Send us an email [email protected] And what would be really helpful is if we could understand what you’re trying to achieve that requires you to need the polarity button because we’re really good at trying to figure out what you’re really asking for and if there’s a set up that you want that’s common. Maybe we would think about just building an amp preset or something to achieve it so that you don’t have to know how to use the priority buttons and it just works. But either way, we’d love to hear from you. The feature requests are always welcome [email protected]

Robert Kazeera says how to identify the problem speakers in a large array hang. He’s referencing a feature in DB where it has some self verification built in. And he also told me later about sometimes he had maybe trouble where he felt like maybe some of the speakers were not making true reports because maybe there’s a reflection because they were too close to the ground. But anyway, maybe you could start by just talking about this self verification feature that is built in.

Yeah. Another excuse why you might not need a measurement Mike. So when we go online with our d&b system, with our one talking to the amplifiers, or even without our one, you can do this. Through the front panel of the amplifier, there’s a function called system check, and this will send almost inaudible low tones and completely inaudible high frequency sounds to the speakers. The amplifier then measures the return impedance and will graph out the impedance measurement of low frequency and of high frequency and of a rear firing driver or a midrange of that cabinet to verify that all of the drivers are operating as a circuit correctly. So this tells us that something is plugged in. It tells us if there’s a broken wire, it tells us if there’s a blown voice coil, all this kind of stuff, and it makes it very quick and easy without making any noise to verify that every speaker is performing electronically up to speed. Now this doesn’t test for things like torn cone or a cabinet rattle or that kind of stuff, but we’re going to get there once we start making noise. So we run system check that verifies the electronic circuits.

Then with vertical line arrays and sometimes other types of arrays, we run a test called array verification, which is just about the most clever thing I’ve ever heard of because we designed the system in a way calc and opened that same project. And R one now knows what amp channel is supposed to be driving which cabinet within our line array, and it initiates a test process where the amp channels, one at a time, will make a low level kind of noise. And while this is happening, it uses all of the adjacent loudspeakers within the array of microphones.

That’s cool, right?

And so by the time it runs this whole test, which takes 1020 seconds for a large array, it will tell you if your line array is wired the same way it expected it to be wired based on how you built your file. And with technologies like array processing, if we had a pair of cables swapped within our fan out, this could have horrendous and unpredictable results. So making sure that every box in the array is actually fed by the right DSP channel is crucially important. So not only will it tell you if it’s patched wrong, it will tell you how it’s patched wrong, which cables are plugged into the wrong cabinet. But what this user is referring to is we have seen times where people run this test before the pace at trim height, which is floating right off the ground. And some of those bottom cabinets are basically firing right into the floor. And this can create reflections, which throws off the test. And in my experience, it’s only happened with J series. There’s something about the LF sensitivities of that box that make it have this issue. And as soon as you take it, like more than 6ft off the ground, then you can run the test without that reflective for being an issue.

Daniel says, how do I combine speakers from different series with unmatched phase response, like the T Ten and the Y seven P? And he sent me a couple of measurements, and I was like, I wonder if those are correct. And I looked them up on the d&b site, and they were, yeah, talk about combining speakers from different families and different series.

Yeah. There are manufacturers that when they come out with a new generation of loudspeaker, they adopt a new phase profile. And this makes it hard to incorporate newer systems and legacy systems into the same PA. Our approach is to try to keep that phase plot as consistent as possible. Over the years, even when we came out with newer apps that are more highly capable, processing wise, we didn’t take that opportunity and just change the phase response to existing speakers. We wanted it, but J series on a D 80 new fancy amp to be exactly the same as a J series on the old two channel amps. We lock in that performance and make it consistent across the world across the decades. And mixing most d&b loudspeakers works really well right out of the box with complementary phase profiles. Now, there are exceptions. The Tseries is a great one. The T series has a very unique acoustic mechanism that affects its phase profile. And here’s how this works. So the T series for everybody doesn’t know it’s a small speaker, and it’s convertible between a point source and a linear box. And it has a rotatable Horn that doesn’t just turn the dispersion on its side.

It actually changes the way the Horn interacts with a secondary acoustic lens, which you can see on the front grille. You see these kind of stripes, this different perforation hole pattern on the front grille. And behind that front grille is a multilayered grill. And these metal perforated metal grill stuff. Multilayered actually affects path length of high frequencies. So when we turn the Horn and it changes the way the HF dispersion interacts with the secondary perforated metal mechanism, it changes the path length, the high frequency, and changes the curvature of the wavefront. So a point source speaker radiates an outward rounded wavefront. And when a Tseries is in a point source mode, it’s 90 X 50, I think. And then when we turn the Horn and we turn the cabinet, it’s now 105 degrees wide by a proportional vertical directivity with a flattened wavefront appropriate for a line source. And the way this works is because of this perforated metal slowing down HF frequencies by extending their path length, which is why the HF phase profile of a Tseries changes depending on the mode it’s in as a byproduct of this mechanical system. And yes, we do have the ability to change it with fancy technology that’s in all these amplifiers apply some Fr filters, all pass filters, all this stuff.

But it would incur latency. So now we have part of our PA at a different latency than the rest of the PA. And it would make Tseries on new amps be different than T series on old amps, which is not something that we want to introduce to our users. So people ask me all the time, though, this is such a cool thing, how come you don’t do this Tseries rotating a Horn perforated metal thing on all the speakers? And now you know why there is a downside. And it works well for a small speaker like a T series.

But that’s not something we want in our Stadium PA. And I remember you saying that in the rare occasion that you would need to combine these two speakers, you just need to make a choice, right?

Yeah. So what part of the frequency bandwidth do you want to have it be aligned? Do you want it for good LF steering and the kind of low, mid and lows want to be perfectly aligned? Or is the T there? For Intelligibility, people commonly use a single T series in the line array mode as a high powered front fill. And in that case, we really care about the HF. So let’s make the HF part of the frequency response align better for alignment with our main system. So, yeah, you make a choice. There’s no such thing as a free lunch and audio. And if you want, like a cool feature like point source to line array, which is highly valuable for small, mid sized rental companies. Then you got to give something else up on the other end. In this case, it’s a non complimentary phase profile.

Yeah, and I’m sure there were conversations on the production side before anything ever happened where they’re like, okay, if we do this, then we’ll have this consequence. And they said it’ll be worth it.

And that’s just another reason why d&b makes 100 different models about speakers, so that you can pick and choose these trade offs as needed for your application, Sunny says.

Why have external amplification rather than built in amps?

Sure. The timeless debate. I see strengths both ways. I used to work for a rental company, a couple, actually, that only had self powered speakers. And from an inventory management point of view, it’s perfect because you never have to think about I’m sending this many speakers, and so how many amps do I need? And every speaker is an amp. So problem solved. Send them out. Don’t have to think about it. On the other hand, if you’re a rental company, it’s a lot more expensive to have an amplifier for every speaker, whereas a lot of rental companies have enough amps to run the A system or the B system, but they never have to run them at the same time so they can buy half as many amps. So there’s that stuff from the commercial side. Then from the technical side, of course, having an amp and a speaker makes it way more. And the question is, do you want that weight in the air? Do you want it on the ground? And amps do fail from time to time. When that failure happens, do you want it in the air? Do you want it on the ground?

Being able to hot swap an amp without having to bring in a rigor or lift is pretty valuable. So there are positives and negatives both ways. I like having one type of cable go up to the array instead of signal amp power. I like having the electronics down on the ground where I can monitor them more easily and troubleshoot them more easily. I like having a lighter array so I can get away with using less rigging and all of that stuff. The roof can only support so much or whatever. So having a light array allows me to use the array I want, not the array I can hang. So that’s easy for me to say. I work for d&b.

And one interesting point I hadn’t thought of before that I remember you telling me about is that if the amp weighs more than the rigging also is going to weigh more because it has to be higher rated to be able to carry heavier weight. And so it’s not just this increase in the weight, but also then the whole thing goes up.

Let’s say we have a really big line array, a maximum hang of 24 boxes. And Germany decided actually for this crossover, we have to use this coil of wire instead of this coil of wire. And the coil wire they want to use is £2 heavier. Not only is the box £2 heavier, but the array is now £48 heavier. And because the array is £48 heavier, the rigging has to be upsized to hold 48 more pounds. But not just the rigging at the top box where the extra £48 happens. But every box has the same rigging, so every box has to have Upsized rigging to hold 48 more pounds. That Upsize rigging now also added 48 more pounds, which means the rigging has to be upsized again to hold an additional 40. Everything is interconnected. So literally every ounce we can shave off of a speaker means £100 in the end or something. Maybe that’s exaggerated, but it’s not just an individual box. It’s quite a lot in the amp. Then at an additional £20 per box is a pretty massive hurdle.

So my friend Steve Knott says, what do you think about renting cranes to hang PA rather than rigging them from Truss? And I said, what specifically do you want to know about? And he said, I’ve seen photos of big festivals where it’s being done already. So I’m curious about the whole thing. Safety rigging for crane lift, stabilizing, aiming the array, and of course, security around the crane base. To make an unclimable sense, wall type deal seems innovative.

I love it. It’s not new either. Doing this for years before line of rays. Even like all rigging, as long as it’s done safely by a qualified and experienced professional, I think it’s wonderful. Personally, I think cranes are a little ugly, so the aesthetic of a giant yellow tractor isn’t my favorite show business aesthetic, but it certainly has logistical benefits. It’s a lot cheaper than paying a crew to come build a tower. I’ve done a lot of outdoor shows where the PA really needed to be in a place that was not conducive to rigging, like on a slope. And with a crane, you can rig it and then drive the crane into position or turn the crane into position. So that’s a huge benefit and it can be totally safe. I strongly suggest at night, between days on site, you bring it in and touch the PA to the ground just in case there was a hydraulic failure. At some point when you’re not there. A lot of times these hydraulic systems, they can have a very slow week and a regular operator wouldn’t notice because a regular operator doesn’t use the crane that just holds something in the air for four days straight, but it can slowly droop.

So let’s be aware of some things like that. But yeah, have a great time. Also, driving cranes and forklifts and lifts is just super fun.

Speaking of driving forklifts, I know you have used an NSL Five, I believe. Can you talk about that for a second.

The MSL Ten.

Msl Ten. These giant Meyer sound speakers.

Yeah, I don’t know. Myers an old company, so I don’t even know if I’d call it an early Myer Speaker, but they’re long gone at this point. But they were so large, a single MSL Ten barely fits into a 53 foot truck like it clears with a couple inches on either side. That’s how large this giant array speaker is. And it was brilliant in that they built slots for Forks from a forklift into the speaker. So you drive the Forks into the speaker. It’s now rigid on the Forks. You pull it out of the truck, you drive it in a position, you take it up in the air, and you turn off the forklift. Congratulations. You’re raised Hong. From logistics point of view, it was amazing. The sound quality could probably be debated. It’s still innovative for the time.

Believe it or not, the first place that I worked for when I moved to the Bay Area had some. They got them second hand somewhere from someone else.

Right. Good times. The last time I was using them was like the amplification for NASCAR, where it’s really about vocal band blunt force SPL. It’s not exactly a nuanced show, and they want it cheap, so being able to rig it without a single hand or crew person helps that be a cheaper installation. It was a great fit for that.

Okay. Wesley Stern, what is their philosophy with main sub crossover? It seems to me that they let their subs low pass filter be much higher than other companies, well above where the main cabs high pass filter is, in most cases resulting in a lot of low midstymation. I really enjoy their systems and the perception this results in.

So he likes that bump in the crossover range. It’s a bit of a misnomer out there that d&b doesn’t allow you to mess with the crossover. We do, but in limited ways. We don’t allow you to actually visualize or just the slopes, but we give you buttons that allow you to tailor the crossover point. And this user is right in that the subs generally go higher in frequency response than most users prefer. We leave it available to you if that’s your approach. But depending on the subwoofer model, it will either have a button called 100 Hz or it will have a button called Infra. Both of these, they lower that low pass filter to cut out some of the upper base. 100 Hz is approximately 100 Hz. Infra is closer to 70 Hz, but changes based on the capabilities of that subwoofer so that you can throttle down the frequency response of that sub and let it focus on the real low stuff, which is more common these days. And Conversely, all of the high mid boxes have a button called Cut, which is a low cut, and it moves up the high pass to cut out some of the well end response at the top.

And between these two buttons, we have four options on how to run this crossover. We can have summation in the crossover point for additional power. We can carve it out to have a little bit less magnitude in the crossover point because maybe we just feel like it’s muddy in that room or with that mix or any combination thereof, and we just toggle the buttons until we like how it sounds. And we have confidence that we haven’t skewed the phase response or made some kind of other compromise because the predetermined friendly buttons that are still compatible and you don’t have to think about it.

Vladimir says subwoofer drive sizes and Uses Is there a trend of releasing 21 in subs, not just from DB, but other brands, too? Did the needs of events change to drive this trend?

I don’t think the needs of the events have changed, but DB has gone to generally larger drivers’than we did in the past, and this is because I think it’s less about the needs of the act and more about the capabilities of the speakers. That’s the thing that’s changed when we had the J series, the kind of gold standard d&b large format PA the tops could go down to. I think it was like 90 Hz or something. Then we had a J sub that was 318s and a J infra that was 321s. A lot of people ran the systems without 21s because the three by 18s with enough low end. Personally, I think once you hear one of these big PA with even just a single infra, it’s hard to use it without because that extra low stuff really feels good. But the reason why there were two models of subs was because the 18 inch drivers could go fast and be high impact, but they couldn’t go very low, whereas the 21s could go really low, but they couldn’t go fast and be high impact. And what’s changed is voice coil technology, particularly with the SL series.

That whole voice coil magnet structure is really reengineered and requires a higher voltage to the voice coil, which the d&b amps are capable of providing. And all of this, in turn, allows the main speaker that goes down to 45 Hz. So we got rid of the upper base requirements out of the Subaru and allowed a 21 inch driver that now has full power even at full excursion, which means as that speaker pushes out, it still has full power to get pulled back to its neutral position as quickly as possible. So now the 21 inch driver can go faster, like an 18 with higher impact, which allows us to be like, oh, the 21 can now do the upper base and the lower base with more impact than the J series could do total. This is a huge win. Let’s go with the 21s. So now that SL sub with 321s not only has the same frequency response as a J sub and a J infra put together, but has almost identical SPL output as a JCB and a junk put together, but weighs less than a J infra by itself.

Okay, so there were some rumblings on Facebook. It seemed like there were a couple of people who are like something about they don’t like d&b phase response and they’re like something about it makes them upset. And our assessment of that is maybe this trend in the market towards flatlines magnitude response phase response. And so I just wanted to give you the floor on that for a minute to maybe address what you think are some of these preconceptions.

Yeah, I think we’ve seen a big marketing push from some manufacturers who are making their face response quote more linear. That is to be like more of a flat line without wraps in the phase response. And DB is not doing this. We’re not into it. We don’t like it. The reason there is we don’t really believe that you’re hearing much of a difference. In the end, we think it’s more of a visual improvement than a Sonic improvement. And there’s no such thing as a free lunch and audio. So just because we can preemptively mess up the signal in exactly the opposite way that the speaker is going to mess it up doesn’t mean we get that for free and doesn’t mean that we don’t incur other side effects in the process. And the main obvious one when it comes to fixing phase response is latency. I think Meyer has a really cool product called the Blue Horn that has a very flat phase response on like 50 Hz or something. And it’s very cool. But as a necessary compromise there, that speaker takes 50 milliseconds for sound to come out 50, right? Chris from Rationale says, yeah, if you want the base to come out the same as the high frequency, you need to think of it like a restaurant.

If the high frequency is your entree, the midrange is your appetizer and the base is your cocktail, you can have them all at once. You just need the kitchen to keep your cocktail and keep your appetizer until the entree is ready. And so same thing with F IR filters and fixing phase. Right? We need to make the high frequency wait, and then we need to make that mid frequency wait until the low frequency is ready to come out of that frame, and then we can align it. And then you end up with 50 milliseconds of latency, which for Bluehorn is totally fine because that is a post production studio environment product where latency isn’t an issue because it’s all playback. A concert, on the other hand, is a different story. That Snare drum already stopped by the time 50 milliseconds goes by. Maybe there’s situations where you could argue that’s, okay, and that latency is still good, but it does come back to my earlier point to the d&b amps have all the ability to make flat phase response right now as is and we could fix it. It takes one of our DSP people like 5 minutes.

It’s not hard. But then that speaker on a D 80 will sound different than the same speaker on an old D twelve and the world of change. And in the end, we don’t really think. We think if we did two versions of the same speaker and we AB them. One had flat phase response, the other one didn’t that you wouldn’t pick the right one if asked to in a blind test.

Nick, where is the best place for people to keep up with you and follow your work?

You can find me on social Nick makes it louder on Instagram, see some pictures of some d&b rigs, a whole bunch of soundscape systems. Otherwise, feel free to send me an email. You can send an email to support us at Dbaudio and just say hey Nick, I had a question about that thing you were talking about or tell me more about this. Anybody anywhere in the world can send an email to [email protected] tell them where you live. That email will get sent to your local support team in your time zone in your native language. Also we have a ton of tutorial [email protected] Everything from software use to wreaking and hey come and say Hi see me at a trade show if those ever start up in postcode come say Hi otherwise you’d be on the internet bar. Yeah. If you bring up the Tiki bar thing to me at a trade show there’s a good chance you’ll end up drinking Tiki drinks on the d&b credit card.

Well, Nick mail. Jerry, thank you so much for joining me on Sound Design Live.

Thanks, Nathan. So much fun.

6 Top Brands, 1 Sub Alignment Method

By Nathan Lively

L-Acoustics, d&b audiotechnik, Coda Audio, RCF, Funktion-One and dB Technologies all recommend the same sub alignment method. It’s no coincidence that SubAligner uses the same method.

I have published several articles discussing this method already, but here’s a quick refresher:

  1. Create an alignment preset for two sources that are equidistant.
  2. Modify that alignment in the field, using delay to equalize any distance offset.

With each of these manufacturer guides there are several commonalities:

  1. Alignment is important. You deserve all of the decibels that you paid for.
  2. If an audio analyzer is unavailable or inappropriate, use the relative/absolute method instead. Some people don’t own an audio analyzer, have not invested the years of practice to master its operation, or don’t have time to set it up. Some circumstances are not appropriate for an audio analyzer, like when the reflections in an arena make the data inactionable.

Interestingly, d&b would like you to start with their modeling software to find alignment, while L-Acoustics eliminates the possibility of LF alignment in their modeling software all together, preferring to provide you with explicit pre-alignment values in their documentation.

L-Acoustics

L-Acoustrics Prest Guide v18.0

It includes pages and pages of pre-alignment delay values depending on which speakers you are combining. SubAligner works the same way, but is not limited to a single manufacturer.

d&b audiotechnik

TI 385 d&b Line array design 10.6

NEXO

NXAMP Manual v3.1

Consequences of a badly aligned system
Precautions
delay
nexo alignment

Coda Audio

LINUS Control v2.2.33 Time Alignment

coda audio max perforamance
Flown systems
coda audio tiray

RCF

Pre-Alignment Delays v.1.1 – Guide EN

Funktion-One

Crossover Settings

dB Technologies

VIO series

This video should start at 2:31.

What about you? Have you tried using the relative/absolute method? What were your results?

How to fight power alley using end-fire arrays

By Nathan Lively

If you don’t like the power alley that results from uncoupled subwoofer arrays and you do have six or more subs and enough real estate, you can try a compromised approach by aiming the left and right energy away from the center, improving isolation and lowering variance across the audience.

I should make it clear that the result appears to reduce the power alley only in contrast to the rest of the audience. There is still interaction in the middle, it’s just lower in level compared to on-axis with the sub arrays.

A reduction of 4dB at 63Hz is found at the center of the audience.

Download the MAPP3D file and run your own tests.

Why six or more?

The 2-element end-fire array is a one note wonder. It cancels at a single frequency in the rear. A more efficient option would be the gradient array, although there are exceptions.

from Subwoofer Array Designer

How do you design an end-fire array?

Space the elements in a line so that their operating frequency range fits nicely in between the preferred filters recommended in Subwoofer Array Designer.

What’s the least amount of cabinets that can be used effectively?

As the number of cabinets goes up, so does the range of cancellation and consistency of coverage.

  • 2 cabinets: Cancellation at 1 frequency. Could be useful for a fighting a single resonant frequency on stage. Otherwise prefer gradient array.
  • 3 cabinets: Cancellation at 2 frequencies. Better an 2. Option to convert to 3-element inverted gradient stack.
  • 4 cabinets: Cancellation at 3 frequencies. Now we’re talkin’.
  • 5 cabinets: Cancellation at 4 frequencies. Even better.
  • 6 cabinets: Cancellation at 5 frequencies. Begin to approach the point of diminishing returns.

Four elements is the most common end-fire quantity because it is effective and reasonably practical. Economizing to three units sharply reduces the randomization in the rear, leading to frequency-dependent reduction. Never end-fire with just two elements. It’s a one-note-wonder on the back side. Use the gradient in-line instead (same physical, different settings). We don’t have to stop at four, bearing in mind that the horizontal pattern narrows with quantity. Get crazy! RF antennas will end-fire 10+ deep.

McCarthy, Bob. Sound Systems: Design and Optimization: Modern Techniques and Tools for Sound System Design and Alignment (p. 321). Taylor and Francis. Kindle Edition.

A more consistent polar pattern?

I had never considered this before Tamas asked about it and I was excited about the possibility. Unfortunately, my experiments do not reveal a significant improvement using 2nd order all-pass filters over pure delay.

FrequencyOpening Angle w/DelayOpening Angle w/APF
40Hz172º160º
50Hz152º152º
63Hz134º144º
80Hz120º116º
100Hz106º100º
100 – 40Hz66º60º

One interesting side effect was the development of a MATLAB script to calculate the ideal frequency and Q parameters for each APF. Let me know if you’re interested in hearing more about that and I can update the article or send you the script.

How do I use SubAligner with end-fire arrays?

Measure the distance to the main array as you normally would, but measure the distance to the furthest subwoofer. All of the other subs in the array are aligned to it as well.

Distance measurements
SubAligner recommendation
SubAligner plot

Here’s a direct link to this alignment if you’d like to use it in SubAligner.

Resulting phase alignment in MAPP 3D
Prediction at 63Hz

Don’t we need to add 4th order filters, as suggested in Subwoofer Array Designer?

Normally, yes, but in this case there is already a native low-pass slope of 24dB/oct.

Have you tried end-fire arrays on your shows? What were your results?

How to phase align main to sub in Smaart, REW, Open Sound Meter, SATlive, and Crosslite

By Nathan Lively

The audio analyzer functions primarily as a verification tool. For this reason this article will focus on creating alignment presets, which can then be modified in the field using simple distance measurements.

To fit this into a single article I will offer an overview of a single method for each software. Although the steps with each tool might differ slightly, in general they follow this pattern:

  1. Measure each source solo.
  2. Do whatever is necessary to achieve alignment.
  3. Measure sources combined and verify summation against a target. Listen.

The Setup

  • Ground-plane.
  • Grille-to-grille (coplanar, side by side).
  • Microphone placed equidistant from each LF driver at a reasonable overall distance in order to capture actionable data and still measure the entire loudspeaker as a whole instead of a single driver or port. For subwoofers, this usually means going outside unless you have a very large room. (approx 5x measurement distance)
with permission from Merlijn van Veen

Set Levels

If you are designing an overlap crossover (+0dB), this is easy. Simply match solo measurements to the target and EQ out the summation bump at the end.

If you are designing a unity class crossover (0dB), this is surprisingly one of the most difficult steps because you want the end result to hit the target, not the individual measurements themselves. The goal is to hit the target in a single step. With most tools you’ll be working in the dark, trying to imagine where the sum is going to end up. This is why there’s a whole subroutine in my SubAligner app dedicated to finding the perfect level relationship to hit the desired target. Shout out to SATlive for being the only software that I now of that includes a perfect addition trace so you can set initial levels without worrying about the alignment right away.

For everyone else, you can start by setting levels at -6dB relative to the target and you’ll probably need to do more adjustments in the end once you see the final result.

Where is the spectral acoustic crossover?

For efficiency, it is recommended to focus on the area of interaction at greatest risk of cancellation where magnitude values are within 10dB of each other, aka the combing and transition zones.

Make the pictures match

Use delay, polarity, and filters to achieve your desired result. Either follow manufacturer specifications or get creative and come up with your own path. Maybe create presets for both and see which one your colleagues prefer in a blind listening test.

A common first step is to achieve alignment at a single starting frequency within the crossover region where you have high confidence (coherence). Find the phase offset (ΔPhase) between main and sub, then close the gap. Since the sources are equidistant, you might want to start with filters, but try both ways. Again, if you’re using a manufacturer’s preset, always start by following their guidelines.

If you’d like to use filters:

  • ΔPhase / 45º = Filter order to try. eg. 90º / 45 º = 2nd order (12dB/oct) filter (Butterworth, Bessel Normalized, and Linkwitz-Riley)
  • For all-pass filters (APF): ΔPhase / 90º = Filter order to try.
  • High-pass filters (HPF) will cause positive phase shift.
  • Low-pass filters (LPF) will cause negative phase shift.
  • It may be easier to see this in action on an unwrapped phase plot.

Applying filters is a big topic outside the scope of this article, but if your interested, please see Phase Alignment Science Academy.

If you’d like to use delay:

  • ΔPhase / 360 / Frequency * 1000 = time in milliseconds
  • If you need to wrap around the top and bottom of the phase graph then use 360 – ΔPhase. eg. If the measured phase offset between two points is 200º, but the traces are near the top and bottom of the graph and you suspect that they need to wrap around, then 360º – 200º = 160º Δphase.
  • Once you have a single frequency aligned, test out other variations at half and whole cycles away. For half cycles, add a polarity inversion. eg. If you’re aligned at 100Hz then try variations at +5ms INV, +10ms, -5ms INV, -10ms.

If you’d like to consult the Southern Oracle, you must first pass the Sphinxes’ Gate and the Magic Mirror Gate.

Verification

After you have tried several variations, choose the one who’s combined result best matches your preferred target. To break a tie, use the option with less delay or less processing overall. Listen to the result or audition multiple presets to find the one that sounds the best.

Smaart

One of the reliable things about Smaart is that the data will never change after it is stored outside from the quick compare function. This means that any change you care to make must be implemented directly in your output processor and then measured in real time.

  1. Add 10ms of delay to both outputs. The amount of delay is arbitrary, but will save you time in step 6.
  2. Measure the Main solo and capture the trace.
  3. Without changing the compensation delay, measure the Sub solo.
  4. Set the sub level to match your target trace. Capture the trace.
  5. Find the spectral crossover using trace offsets.
  6. Make the pictures match.
  7. Verify alignment and summation. Listen.
  8. Remove any extra delay left over from step 1. 

Here’s an example combining an L-Acoustics X15-HiQ with an SB118. Initial measurements reveal a 38º phase offset between them. We might first attempt to close this gap with 1.16ms of delay on the sub (38º / 360 / 91Hz * 1000), but further tests would reveal an improved alignment with a half cycle of delay and polarity inversion in the main.

Recommendations from SubAligner and the L-Acoustics Preset Guide confirm this result. If you’re a SubAligner user you can open this direct link to the alignment.

Tips: For high quality actionable data I recommend setting temporal averaging to Inf and resetting the averages with each new measurement. Consider downloading measurements from the manufacturer, Tracebook, or SubAligner in order to have some expectations to work against.

REW

The rest of the audio analyzers covered in this article offer functions to simulate output processing. In REW the EQ window allows you to experiment with different filters and then generate a new measurement that includes those filters. Then you can experiment with gain, delay, and polarity using the Alignment Tool and its auto solver options.

  1. Measure Main solo.
  2. Estimate IR Delay. Shift and Update Timing Reference.
  3. Measure Sub.
  4. Find the spectral crossover using Measurement Actions.
  5. Experiment with filters and the Alignment Tool to make the pictures match. Generate an Aligned Sum for each variation.
  6. Compare all of the Aligned Sum variations for alignment and summation. Listen.

Tips: For high quality actionable data I recommend setting the number of measurement repetitions to 8 and the length to 256k.

Open Sound Meter

  1. Measure the Main solo and capture the trace.
  2. Without changing the compensation delay, measure the Sub solo. Capture the trace.
  3. Set the sub level to match your target trace.
  4. Find the spectral crossover using gain changes.
  5. Make the pictures match. You can click on a measurement and adjust its delay and polarity while watching a sum trace calculated with File > Add math source.
  6. Verify alignment and summation. Listen.

In this image you can see me creating the sum trace on the left and then manipulating the main trace on the right to achieve better summation.

SATlive

SATlive includes some of my favorite tools for crossover alignment, which were my inspiration for getting started with SubAligner. The Live Add trace gives you a real time crystal ball preview of what the combination of main and sub will look like. The Perfect addition trace creates a target so you can see how well you are doing. The Delay-Suggestion Tool will run an auto solver and make recommendations for delay and polarity. The Area Of Interaction Tool can be used to visualize the crossover region.

  1. Measure the Main solo and capture the trace.
  2. Without changing the compensation delay, measure the Sub solo. Capture the trace.
  3. Set the sub level to match your target trace while observing the Perfect Addition trace.
  4. Find the spectral crossover using the Area Of Interaction tool.
  5. Make the pictures match with the aid of the Delay-Suggestion Tool.
  6. Verify alignment and summation by comparing the Live Add Trace against the Perfect Addition Trace. Listen.
satlive

Crosslite

Crosslite also includes auto solver functions, but instead of using a brute force iterative approach, it will attempt to align the start or peak of the impulse responses, which can be filtered to focus on the crossover region. One of my favorite tools in Crosslite is the cursor. It can be enabled to find the phase difference between measurements and even converted into time for the alignment. Crosslite also offers various filter options and can be thought of as a full DSP simulator.

  1. Capture the Main and Sub solo.
  2. User Memories > Functions > Sum > Process Method > Sum Magnitude to generate a perfect addition trace. Adjust the sub level until the Sum Magnitude matches your target trace.
  3. Find the spectral crossover either using Gain or cursors.
  4. Make the pictures match. The most efficient starting point may be found by inserting a peak filter at the input around the center of the crossover region and running the Optimize Time function. Experiment with changing the alignment to rise or peak and the filter from normal phase to phase zero. The best option here may depend on the quality of the measurement data. Always check the phase graph afterwards.
  5. Verify alignment and summation. Listen.

Next Steps

Now that you’ve created an alignment preset, it can be deployed and modified in the field using distance measurements. If you’d like to send me the speaker measurements you took along the way, I’ll add them to the SubAligner app.

How to practice at home without a PA

You can download lots of high quality data from Tracebook to practice with.

Have you tried any of these softwares? What method do you use to optimize phase alignment between main and sub?

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 18
  • Next Page »

Search 200 articles and podcasts

Copyright © 2022 Nathan Lively

 

Loading Comments...